It doesn’t get more dramatic than this. New York City FC hosts Charlotte FC at Yankee Stadium on September 20, 2025, and both teams know exactly what’s at stake — playoff survival. For NYCFC, every point matters in the Eastern Conference battle, while Charlotte arrives hoping to spoil the party and boost their own postseason chances. This is the kind of MLS clash where nerves, noise, and ninety minutes of chaos collide.
Recent Form – Both teams are in good form
NYCFC are fighting inconsistency. A big 3-1 win over Chicago was followed by a frustrating loss to DC United. The talent is there — Alonso Martínez continues to deliver goals, while Nicolás Fernández is starting to look like a real midfield gem. But defensively, lapses still haunt them.
Charlotte FC is in really good form. They beat Inter Miami 3-0, followed by an impressive win against New England. They’re not blowing teams away. Their 3-0 win over Inter Miami showed resilience, and striker Toklomati Jorno looks dangerous again. If they can keep it tight and frustrate NYCFC, Charlotte has a chance at stealing something here.
Team News – Who’s In, Who’s Out?
NYCFC: Malachi Jones is still recovering, while N. Cavallo remains doubtful. Expect Alonso Martínez to lead the front, with Fernández pulling strings behind him.
Charlotte: Their midfield looks strong, with Ashley Westwood fit. KC Vargas controls the tempo of the match, but they’ll miss defender Andrew Privett due to suspension.
Both sides are carrying knocks, but no major long-term absentees to completely derail their plans.
Charlotte FC vs New York City FC Predicted Lineups
Charlotte FC (4-3-3)
| Position | Player |
|---|---|
| GK | K. Kahlina (8.3) |
| RB | N. Byrne (7.0) |
| CB | T. Ream (7.3) |
| CB | A. Malanda (7.0) |
| LB | J. Marshall-Rutty (7.1) |
| CM | A. Westwood (c) (7.3) |
| CM | K. C. Vargas (7.7) |
| CM | D. Diani (6.7) |
| RW | W. Zaha (7.2) |
| ST | I. Toklomati Jorno (9.2) |
| LW | B. Bronico (7.1) |
New York City FC (4-2-3-1)
| Position | Player |
|---|---|
| GK | M. Freese (6.8) |
| RB | T. Gray (6.6) |
| CB | T. Martins (c) (6.6) |
| CB | Raul Gustavo (6.8) |
| LB | K. O’Toole (7.2) |
| CM | J. Haak (7.0) |
| CM | A. O’Neill (6.8) |
| RW | H. Wolf (6.5) |
| CAM | M. Moralez (7.5) |
| LW | N. Fernández (7.4) |
| ST | A. Martínez (6.8) |
Tactical Battle – Midfield Will Decide It
This game will be won in the middle. NYCFC’s double pivot of J. Haak and A. O’Neill will try to control tempo, while Charlotte’s Westwood and D. Diani will look to disrupt and hit on transitions. Expect Wilfried Zaha to drift into pockets, trying to unlock Toklomati Jorno with through balls.
If NYCFC press high and play quickly, they can overwhelm Charlotte. But if Charlotte drags them into a scrappy fight, things get tense.
Head-to-Head Snapshot
The last five meetings? Tight. NYCFC have taken two, Charlotte one, with two draws mixed in. Yankee Stadium has usually favored the hosts, but Charlotte are no pushover — they love upsetting bigger teams when least expected.
Key Players to Watch
New York FC (official)
NYCFC:
Alonso Martínez – the man who makes things happen up front.
Maxi Moralez – with abilities of high pressing and playmaking
Charlotte:
Wilfried Zaha – if he finds space, NYCFC’s defense is in trouble.
Toklomati Jorno – A real threat to NYCFC defenders
Midfield Duel: Nicolás Fernández vs Ashley Westwood — creativity vs control.
Where to Watch – Kickoff Times & Channels
USA: 7:30 PM ET, live on Apple TV (MLS Season Pass).
UK: 12:30 AM BST (Sept 21), stream on Apple TV (MLS Season Pass).
India: 5:00 AM IST (Sept 21), live on Apple TV (MLS Season Pass).
No regional blackouts — every fan can stream it globally with MLS Season Pass.
Prediction – Drama at Yankee Stadium
This one feels like classic MLS chaos. NYCFC have the talent, Charlotte have the grit. With home fans behind them, NYCFC should just edge it.
Predicted Score: NYCFC 2-1 Charlotte FC
But don’t be shocked if Charlotte nick a draw. Playoff football is all about fine margins.
For football fans: This is one of those nights where anything can happen — so football fans, don’t even think about missing this clash at Yankee Stadium.
Featured Image – Major League Soccer (Official)
By
